Why Would We Want Realistic Videogames?

For some reason ever since I was born, I’ve heard an odd complaint about videogames. I often hear people say that they’re not realistic, or ask “why play a videogame when you can go outside instead?” The weirdest comment I hear is when someone who doesn’t understand watches someone play a videogame and then points out that something that happened in the game “wasn’t realistic.” I’ve got to ask when was the purpose of a videogame to be “realistic?”

From the ancient days of gaming, Pac Man wasn’t realistic, Mario wasn’t realistic, and very few games have ever actually strived to be realistic. Playing a videogame has never been about trying to replicate real life. The only time’s a videogame has been made to replicate real life, is when doing that thing in real life is either extremely impractical, or dangerous. For example, simulation racing games and military simulation games. However, even these games cut some corners for the sake of time. People often see a game like Call of Duty, Battlefield, or Need for Speed, and see just how realistic the graphics are and hear the amazingly realistic sound effects. But seem to completely miss the point that these games have very simple and arcade-style controls. I promise that every game ever has never strived to completely replicate real life. Instead, videogames take inspiration from real life and the developers then tweak reality to fit into the medium and make it more fun.

Even with the latest and most immersive gaming experience, virtual reality (VR) doesn’t strive for complete realism. I love this game called Onward, it technically falls under the category of being a military simulator. You are equipped with realistic weapons that function just like real weapons and you a few other pieces of gear and your squad is on a mission to clear an area of enemies or to evacuate an area with as few casualties as possible. However, when you or a teammate get injured, you don’t have to do CPR or wrap them up with bandages or use your rifle as a crutch. No, of course not cause that would slow the pace of the game and be really inconvenient. You will move slower if injured or be laying on the ground dying, but in order to be healed, your teammate simply needs to poke you with a needle that instantly heals you. It’s not realistic, but in VR the simple act of bending down and pulling out a needle to help your friend, get’s the point across. The most high-end VR experience right now is probably a game called Half-Life: Alyx. Alyx is a sci-fi combat and puzzle-solving game, but to make the game less tedious the game gives you “gravity gloves” which let you select a small object like a pop can or a gun and with a flick of your wrist, pulls the item to you and you can catch it with ease. It’s not realistic, but it makes doing many miscellaneous tasks more bearable and actually really fun.

Lastly, I want to address the idea of “why not just go outside and play.” This is pretty stupid because in real life I don’t own a spaceship and I’m not at war with an army of killer robots. Also in real life, I don’t want to be at war. We can’t do 99% of the things in a video game, in real life. Even things that are very similar to videogames still aren’t the same experience. And finally, doing things in real life won’t allow me and my friends to instantly connect to a whole new world, with its own laws of physics with its own, story, history, and more to kill one another and then between moments of tension, let me pick up a mug of tea next to me and take a sip.

Gaming has the ability to be the most fun, most frustrating, most difficult, most social, most stressful, most relaxing, most engaging, and most therapeutic hobby all at the same time. I am looking forward to full-body VR where I can run, jump, crawl, and climb in a realistic video game. But unlike real life, I want to be in deadly combat without the risk of actually dying. So I ask the question, why in the world would anyone want videogames to be like real life? Let me shoot nazi’s one second and sip my tea the next.




Life Advice | Self-Improvement | Gaming | Short Stories

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

OXS: Building Mechas with MECHACHAIN [RESUMED!]

Bored Button Games- The Narnia Cupboard For Games

NES/Famicom: a visual compendium


The Murky Definition of Interactive Fiction

How do Game-related Problem shape Game Design Ethics?

Dalarnian Almanac: Game Economics, Part 1 — Miners

PS5 v/s XBOX: How big is the difference?

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Tannar Thompson

Tannar Thompson

Life Advice | Self-Improvement | Gaming | Short Stories

More from Medium

Why did the Slovenian Philosopher Slavoj Zizek say love is evil?

We The People

image of a digital man

The True Cost of MetaVerse Denial